Last updated: 9 September 2026
Lily’s Kitchen vs Forthglade is most useful as an exact-recipe comparison. Both sell complete wet food, but their ranges also differ in formats and recipe details. Choose a suitable meal, calculate the daily amount, then compare cost and convenience. There is no defensible universal winner based only on the front of the pack.
To make the comparison concrete, this guide uses Lily’s Kitchen Chicken & Turkey Casserole in a 400g tin and Forthglade adult Turkey & Brown Rice in a 395g tray. These are wholegrain examples. Do not transfer the details below to either brand’s puppy, grain-free or other wet recipes.
Table of Contents
What the two labels tell you
| Detail | Lily’s Kitchen example | Forthglade example |
|---|---|---|
| Recipe | Chicken & Turkey Casserole | Adult Turkey & Brown Rice |
| Complete meal? | Yes, per manufacturer | Yes, per manufacturer |
| Pack | 400g tin | 395g tray |
| Published energy | 92kcal per 100g | 127kcal per 100g |
| Key recipe distinction | Contains chicken and turkey, with grains including barley and rice | Turkey and brown-rice recipe |
These manufacturer figures were checked on 9 September 2026. Always read the delivered pack, because recipes and labelling can change. The table establishes practical differences; it does not grade digestibility, long-term health or whether a particular dog will enjoy either food.
The nearly identical pack size hides an energy difference
Using those published energy values, a 400g Lily’s tin contains about 368kcal. A 395g Forthglade tray contains about 502kcal. Replacing one whole pack with the other is therefore not an equal-energy swap.
For a purely illustrative 300kcal food allocation, the arithmetic gives approximately 326g of the Lily’s example or 236g of the Forthglade example. That is not a daily recommendation for any dog. It demonstrates why you should compare the intended ration rather than assume “one tray equals one tin”.
If your dog receives other food, chews or rewards, those belong in the same overall feeding plan. Ask for help calculating the ration when a veterinary condition, weight-management plan or growth stage makes the decision more complex.
Compare prices using the same method
Record each offer’s total delivered price and total food weight. Divide the price by grams, then multiply by the relevant daily grams for that recipe. Keep introductory subscription offers separate from the ongoing price so the comparison still makes sense next month.
This article contains Amazon affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Find Lily’s Kitchen Chicken & Turkey Casserole (6 × 400g) on Amazon UK. You can also Find Forthglade Turkey & Brown Rice complete food (18 × 395g) on Amazon UK. Check that the multipack contains the intended recipe rather than several flavours. A cheaper-looking alternative listing may contain fewer packs or a different product line.
Suppose two packs happened to have the same shelf price. Their daily cost could still differ because the appropriate portions differ. Conversely, a cheaper calculated ration may be less convenient if it leaves an awkward amount that cannot be used within storage instructions.
Tin or tray: the everyday differences
A tin needs a suitable way to cover leftovers and space in the fridge once opened. A tray needs the same attention to covering, refrigeration and opening dates, even if its shape makes it easier to stack. Follow each recipe’s actual instructions rather than borrowing a storage period from another brand.
Consider who feeds the dog. One person weighing a portion may find either pack straightforward. A household where several people share meals benefits from a written daily amount and a clearly labelled opened pack. The convenient package is the one that makes the correct routine easy to repeat.
Do not confuse the Forthglade ranges
Forthglade’s wet range includes complete meals and complementary products. A Just tray with a prominent meat percentage is not automatically a substitute for the complete Turkey & Brown Rice recipe compared here. Read the status on the exact listing and packet.
Likewise, “Lily’s Kitchen” is not a single formula. The chicken-and-turkey recipe here is not suitable for an owner trying to exclude chicken simply because the comparison headline mentions turkey elsewhere.
Which should you choose?
Choose the Lily’s example if its exact recipe suits your dog and the tin format, portion size and current delivered cost fit your routine. Choose the Forthglade example if that recipe and tray format work better after calculating the correct amount. If both qualify, try a modest quantity before committing to a large repeating order.
Our dog food delivery guide covers delivery arrangements, while the main food guide helps compare broader formats. Judge the final choice by a suitable diet you can feed consistently, not a brand-level score that ignores the product in your cupboard.